Springfield: Police Chiefs Group Questions Handling of Chief Cook Case
Police & Fire·November 12, 2026

Springfield: Police Chiefs Group Questions Handling of Chief Cook Case

Robert Hargrove · Union County Life

According to the Union County Police Chiefs Association.

The Union County Police Chiefs Association used public comment at the Springfield Township Committee's Oct. 27 meeting to ask four questions about how the township has handled the case of Police Chief John Cook.

The speaker was Matthew Nazzaro, Cranford's police chief and a vice president of the association. The association's website lists him as second vice president.

Nazzaro said he was speaking for the association and that due process should be the theme of the matter. He said the association understood from counsel that the committee would not answer the questions. He said the group still wanted to put them forward for the committee to consider.

The association asked:

What legal or procedural basis the township believes gives it authority to discipline Cook after, according to the association, he was cleared by the Union County Prosecutor's Office.

Whether the township did its own independent investigation, and if so, what new evidence or substantiated findings justify disciplinary action.

How the township justifies seeking to terminate Cook. The association describes him as a decorated chief with more than 37 years of service and an exemplary record.

What documented justification exists for removing Cook from his position and immediately placing him on administrative leave.

Nazzaro said information the township released in a Friday afternoon announcement "didn't allow for the whole story to be told." He said the association hopes that day will come. He also said Cook "deserves due process for all that he's done for the township."

He said the association shares the township's stated commitment to a fair process and dependable police services for Springfield. "We're in alignment," he said.

The meeting video does not show a committee response to the questions during that public comment period.

The committee read a statement before adjourning its Oct. 16 special meeting. It said the committee "did not reach this decision lightly." It also said the committee had considered whether the matter could be resolved without formal charges and "regrets that it concluded there was no responsible alternative to bringing them."

The committee said the issues must be addressed through the process set by law, which gives the chief a chance to respond. "Allegations are not findings of misconduct and the chief is entitled to a fair opportunity to respond to any charges properly brought," the statement said.

The committee said it "has not made a final disciplinary determination." It said confidentiality rules on personnel and internal affairs matters prevent it from discussing the allegations publicly. It said it will share more information when the law authorizes or requires disclosure.

The statement closed by saying the committee is committed "to a fair process, responsible government, and dependable police services for Springfield."

Find more Springfield events, businesses, and local news on Union County Life.

Source: Union County Police Chiefs Association (ucpca.org); Township of Springfield meeting video

Photo: Mr. Matté / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0). The November 2025 photo shows the Springfield Township Municipal Building. It is not a photo of the police department, Chief Cook, Chief Nazzaro, or the meeting.

Frequently asked questions

What did the Union County Police Chiefs Association ask Springfield about Chief John Cook?

At the Oct. 27 Township Committee meeting, the association asked four questions. It asked what legal basis the township has to discipline Cook, whether the township did its own investigation and what new findings it has, how it justifies seeking to terminate him, and what documented reason exists for placing him on administrative leave.

What has the Springfield Township Committee said about the Chief Cook case?

At its Oct. 16 special meeting, the committee said the issues must go through the process set by law, which gives the chief a chance to respond. It said allegations are not findings of misconduct, and that confidentiality rules prevent it from discussing the allegations publicly.

Has Springfield made a final decision on Chief Cook?

Not as of the committee's Oct. 16 statement. The committee said it has not made a final disciplinary determination and will share more information when the law authorizes or requires it.

Related articles

Get Union County news in your inbox

Subscribe for local headlines, town updates, and community stories from across Union County.

Sign up for the newsletter
Viviana Zapata, REALTOR®

YOUR UNION COUNTY REAL ESTATE EXPERT

Viviana Zapata

REALTOR® · Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Elite

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson · NJ · 181 North Ave East, Cranford NJ

Union County Life's real estate content, listings, and IDX data are presented under the license and control of Viviana Zapata, REALTOR®. All property searches and listing displays on this site are Viviana's displays.

Viviana Zapata, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson. Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Elite. 181 North Avenue East, Cranford, NJ 07016. Member NJMLS, CJMLS, GSMLS. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of Garden State Multiple Listing Service. Real estate listings held by other brokerage firms are marked as IDX Listing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. © 2026 Garden State MLS. All rights reserved.